Manuscript Reader
|
Loading manuscript document...
📄
Manuscript for Review
Manuscript Title
Abstract
Abstract text...
Source Document: manuscript.docx
Author submitted file in Word (.docx) format. Click below to review full text.
Reviewer Evaluation Form
Aries Editorial Manager® Standard Evaluation Rubric
Form Progress:
20%
📊 Part I: Scientific Criteria Evaluation Matrix
Scale: 1 (Poor) to 5 (Outstanding)| Evaluation Criterion | 1 Poor |
2 Fair |
3 Good |
4 Very Good |
5 Outstanding |
|---|
☑️ Part II: Reviewer Questionnaire & Compliance
1. Is the subject matter suitable for Davao Research Journal?
2. Are statistical analyses robust and correctly interpreted?
3. Is the language, clarity, and academic writing acceptable?
4. Are there any competing or financial conflicts of interest?
Transmitted directly to authors upon decision
Please structure feedback with Major Strengths, Major Concerns (methodology, theory, data), and Minor Suggestions (figures, citations).
Strictly NOT revealed to authors
Required for submission